To ROCKSTAR FREDDY: I ain't an expert of fanboi world and kawaii designs, but eh, I've seen pretty f%*ked up things in Deviantart reguarding you. And stop bickering, you're a bear and he's a woodchipper
Maybe he meant Handsome Freddy, so Rockstar Freddy
To Freddy: If that's the case...
?OH SAY CAN YOU SEE?
?By THE DAWN'S EARLY LIGHT?
?WHAT SO PROUDLY WE HAILED?
?IN THE TWILIGHT'S LAST GLEAMING?
**To Freddy, glancing at the top hat**: ?GOD SAVE OUR GRACIOUS QUEEN...?
To Mr. Afton: Ye know, that place which signed your doom. The trap Henry prepared for you. Your plans of destruction and slaughter would be stopped by Henry and the Infamous Burning of Freddy Fazbear's Pizza Place. You were burned. You never came back.
To Springtrap: You don't always come back. Not after FFPS at least.
To The Nightmare: It's the 8th Night but whatever. Why did we start reparteeing again?
To The Nightmare: There is still one small question tickling my brains. How did you appear in your own nightmares before dying?
To The Nightmare: Y'know what, this makes me kind of more respect you. Only one question, though.
Y o u a r e t h e C R Y I NG C H I L D ????
This is answering so many questions to me and to all the people on the other side of the screen right now! The color black, death simbol, your analogy with Fredbear's Family Diner... to think we used to call you Nightmare Shadow Freddy or something before Sister Location came out. Your reply to my well-thinked theories completely shatters them! Anyway, I'm just trying to win a discussion with the Puppeteer, or The Guy on the Other Side of Another Screen, pulling the strings behind your and all the others' life and afterlife.
But this brings so many other answers, like the half-baked origin of FNaF World. It was Daydream's doing, wasn't it?
To Nightmare Cupcake: Rude.
To Nightmare Freddy (may he judge if giving this opinion to the rest of the Nightmare Crew or not): in conclusion, I think that "The" Nightmare is after all just that: a nightmare. An illusion. He's not that good of a leader if he has to handle you guys, having your butt kicked singularly makes him feel stronger, but uniting all the nightmares would make him hope he was never born. He's so strong and mighty and powerful in a dream, or in a game he even manages to crash, but in real life? Behind the screen, he's just a punk, a bully already fading away on its own. In UCN, he has to work in couple with Nightmare Fredbear to be of any threat. He's substituted by Nightmarionne - a skinny, terrific looking Puppet, but only slightly weaker than Balloon Boy or another low-tier animatronic, and not even canon - in the Halloween Edition, not handling the metaphysical stress of being in the incarnation of what he believes himself to be.
Even this absurde rivalry with the Fazbears you claim to have, has begun with "The" Nightmare showing off as a leader. With Shadow Freddy you were relaxed, at least slightly more than you are with The Nightmare, as he was more kind of a leader. "The" Nightmare is a boss. Working on its own once and merely making an odd noise, while y'all succeeded to repeatedly jumpscare Kid Rambo and his backflips.
For Scott's sake, this "The" Nightmare dude is scared by light! A literal flashlight YOU guys often manage to ignore! So I suppose you might do one of the following:
1: End this absurde rivalry with the Fazbears and send away The Nightmare
2: Take Nightmarionne as your leader
3: Keep following The Nightmare in the manner of a sheep and use these darn expedients.
His signs of weakness are evident, how could I not realize before that he is just an illusionary bad guy, shielded by his gang he has to convince by channeling all his power in a Zaplock and kicking all their asses at once (probably ending up having to rest several hours afterwards). Has one of you guys ever tried to Zaplock someone? I bet you could do much, much better than him!
To Nightmare Freddy: short... Tempered... God? Wasn't he once just a random animatronic living in a dead kid's nightmares and speficically in the last night, hidden, and looking like a blacked out version of Nightmare Fredbear? Aight, whatever. Try your best, after all you dealt with him for much longer than I did.
Just to say, though, the FazPuppet is a permanent resident inside a kid's nightmares as well, only called "Faz" by his builder. He was meant for this, William can confirm.
Sounds plausible
To NIGHTMARE FREDDY: hecc, maybe a Puppet show organized by the FazPuppet? Be aware, I have many more tricks up my sleeves
To NIGHTMARE FREDDY: don't worry, everything will be fine. Plus, if all fails, I'll send in some helping hands called Nightmareenas to calm down The Nightmare by dancing
To NIGHTMARE FREDDY: if he freaks out about it, it's perfect for a test drive.
For what purpouse
To NIGHTMARE FREDDY: All right, here's one. If he ever freaks out, press the Bright Red Obvious Button™ and he'll calm down. If that doesn't work, use this lever to give him some Star Wars comics to read and some prequel memes.
*whispering to Nightmare Freddy* Just in case, did you keep the Nightmare Shutdown Switch I sent you for Christmas?
*Evily cackling* To The Nightmare: I'm pretty sure that in this place the animatronic Luke Skywalker is represented by Plushtrap... *More silent cackling as the instincts of The Nightmare (Darth Fredbear) start to kick in*
To Nightmare Fredbear: Are you concerned about the fact that your brother Nightmare has become Darth Fredbear?